Annex 3

Suitability Policy – Summary of Consultation Responses

	Crimes resulting in death or intended to cause death or serious injury– no elapsed period			Exploitation – no elapsed period			Offences involving violence – 10 years				Possession of a weapon or any other weapon related offence – 7 years				Sex and indecency offences – no elapsed period
	Agree	Disagree	Not Answered	Agree	Disagree	Not Answered	Agree	Too Long	Too Short	Not Answered	Agree	Too Long	Too Short	Not Answered	Agree	Disagree	Not Answered
Calderdale	115	63	7	111	63	11	65	86	28	6	85	52	42	5	107	75	3
Kirklees	111	45	1	116	39	2	69	61	26	1	73	43	40	1	110	46	1
Leeds	194	41	5	194	41	5	203	24	23	0	194	19	37	0	182	68	0
Wakefield	33	17	0	36	14	0	10	38	3	0	17	27	7	0	32	18	0
York	42	8	0	39	11	0	21	23	3	3	35	4	9	2	38	11	1
Combined Results	495	174	13	496	168	18	368	232	83	10	404	145	135	8	469	218	5

	Dishonesty offences – 7 years				Drugs supply – 10 years				Drugs use – 5 years				Discrimination – 7 years				Drink driving/ driving under the influence of drugs – 7 years
	Agree	Too Long	Too Short	Not Answered	Agree	Too Long	Too Short	Not Answered	Agree	Too Long	Too Short	Not Answered	Agree	Too Long	Too Short	Not Answered	Agree	Too Long	Too Short	Not Answered
Calderdale	86	81	13	5	115	28	35	7	110	33	36	6	106	60	15	4	105	32	42	6
Kirklees	75	62	19	1	95	34	27	1	88	36	33	0	91	54	12	0	84	32	39	2
Leeds	203	35	12	0	196	13	41	0	201	22	27	0	213	21	16	0	200	12	38	0
Wakefield	10	38	3	0	30	13	7	0	27	12	12	0	19	30	2	0	32	10	9	0
York	26	20	3	1	29	14	7	0	26	15	9	0	33	14	2	1	39	5	6	0
Combined Results	400	236	50	7	465	102	117	8	452	118	117	6	462	179	47	5	460	91	134	8

	Driving whilst using a hand-held telephone or other device – 5 years				Minor traffic or vehicle related offences – 5 years				Major traffic or vehicle related offences – 7 years				Hackney carriage and private hire offences – 7 years				Vehicle use offences – 7 years
	Agree	Too Long	Too Short	Not Answered	Agree	Too Long	Too Short	Not Answered	Agree	Too Long	Too Short	Not Answered	Agree	Too Long	Too Short	Not Answered	Agree	Too Long	Too Short	Not Answered
Calderdale	71	87	19	8	62	111	8	4	94	65	24	3	73	92	11	9	75	98	11	1
Kirklees	64	71	19	3	59	93	4	1	74	63	17	3	68	77	11	1	72	73	9	3
Leeds	200	44	6	0	185	61	4	0	201	28	12	0	199	42	9	0	212	29	9	0
Wakefield	5	45	0	0	4	46	1	0	12	37	2	0	7	39	4	0	12	39	0	0
York	14	34	0	2	17	32	0	1	33	10	3	4	19	28	0	3	26	22	0	2
Combined Results	354	281	44	13	327	343	17	6	414	203	58	10	366	278	35	13	397	261	29	6

	Requirement to subscribe to DBS Update Service			Certificate of good conduct
	Yes	No	Not Answered	Yes	No	Not Answered
Calderdale	113	67	5	88	90	7
Kirklees	118	38	1	108	47	2
Leeds	235	15	0	6	9	235
Wakefield	31	20	0	24	27	0
York	46	4	0	48	1	1
Combined Results	543	144	6	274	174	245

Represents a majority of the number of responses in favour of the proposal

Represents a majority of the number of responses against the proposal

Summary of respondents

	Calderdale	Kirklees	Leeds	Wakefield	York
Total Number of Responses	185	168	250	51	50
Type:
A licensed driver	116	93	-	42	17
A licensed private hire operator	4	13	-	1	3
A licensed vehicle proprietor	3	2	-	1	17
A member of the public	58	60	19	6	2
A licensed driver/ a proprietor	-	-	-	-	9
A licensed driver/private hire operator	-	-	-	-	1
A licensed driver/a proprietor/private hire operator	-	-	227	-	-
Other	4	-	4	1	1